Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Petra Benes's avatar

Love this sentence: “The tempo of the tool becomes the tempo you feel you have to match with your judgement.”

I’m not sure AI versus humans is the real discussion. The value of another mind - human or AI - isn’t necessarily that it is unbiased. Is there even such a thing as an unbiased mind? The value can be that it contributes something outside your own thinking.

What you do with that then becomes the issue. Do you accept it? Question it? Challenge it? Ask it to validate what you already decided?

My own response to AI is often: “No, that’s not it / not quite right.” Then I have to articulate why. The correction itself sharpens my thinking.

Humans and AI can both become echo chambers. It depends partly on who or what we surround ourselves with, but also on what we ask of them. My AI agents are explicitly instructed to leave out the cheerleading unless it is earned.

I would add one thing on intuition too: I don’t experience gut feeling and intuition as the same thing, and I don’t think all internal signals depend on previous patterns. We already touched on that in one of your previous articles.,but I think it matters here because it affects how we judge what AI can and cannot help us evaluate.

Such an interesting topic, and I think there’s much more to explore here. Because ultimately this may be less about our relationship with AI than our relationship with ourselves. If we were already used to outsourcing our judgement to other people, why would that necessarily change with AI?

In the end, whether it’s AI or another human, it comes down to how much we trust ourselves and our own judgement, particularly when someone or something disagrees with us. Use both to expand your thinking. But don’t outsource your judgement.

1 more comment...

Ready for more?