If you ask ten people what are the top five things you can do with your hands, I bet hardly any of them will tell you that your hands are excellent for speaking. Unless they are Italians. And even then, most of us are so used to using our hands to communicate that we all take it for granted, sometimes becoming a beloved foreign laughing stock. But talking with your hands does wonders for the speaker and the audience, which is why I include hand gesturing while speaking among the things that matter if you want to train your intuition.
However gesturing is still not necessarily popular at work. “Try not to be so passionate” is something I have heard multiple times, most memorably from a colleague whose own family had arrived in Britain a generation earlier, from a part of Asia that carries the same passionate reputation Italians do. But they have not developed hand-gesture as much as Italians have.
My take is that he had worked very hard at keeping still. I see the same thing in my two daughters, born to immigrant parents, working very hard on anything they subconsciously associate to be stereotypically British, from composure to lack of passion to their accents. They find it something to hold on to in a desperate need to fit in. But the struggles of immigrant parents and first generation children and their quest to be accepted doesn’t belong to this series so I will leave it alone.
After researching the benefits of hand gesturing associated with fostering intuitive signalling in ourselves and others, what I wanted to find out was why Italians spoke with their hands and the British didn’t. Some online references to busy marketplaces and the variety of dialects present in Italy felt slightly superficial and unconvincing to me, so I dug deeper into history.
Why Italians speak with their hands
I started from a little refresh on Italian history, which seemed like the obvious place for my investigation. The top line is that Italy has been one country for the last 165 years. Before, it was a series of city states with their own dialects, with roughly half of this time spent as a republic, as the king was sent away and the monarchy abolished in 1946. There is a role that monarchy has to play with hand-gesture and we will come to it later.
During the years, from the Etruscans to the Romans, Italy’s trading partners and the fact that it had been invaded for centuries by foreign populations, Greeks in the south, Normans in Sicily, Spanish and Austrians later, made a developed hand signing language a necessity and not a nice to have. It most likely also allowed people to speak behind the back of the latest ruler in a way that was harder to trace.
Why the British learned to keep still
England had a lot of varied languages too. From Welsh to Gaelic to Old Norse. The difference is that the Tudors did a brilliant job since 1500 to eradicate, and social police, any alternative form of communication they could not understand, and hence control. The “King’s English” became the only language accepted for law, trade and administration.
They went even further and built stigma and social status associated with “the stiff upper lip” as the only acceptable way to be. Still and controlled was good, opposite to the “uncivilised” gesturing Italians used to communicate, even accounted for by British travellers coming back from Italy in the sixteenth and seventeenth century, as uncivilised and vulgar. Heavily relying on verbal language only became the thing classy British had to comply with.
Where gesture became a full language
Italians have 250 codified gestures uniting us as a nation, and almost all other Mediterranean populations from Spanish to Israelis use gestures profusely, even though they never quite got to the fame Italians achieved as hand talkers. 250 codified gestures is nothing in comparison to the thousands of unique signs the Native American tribes devised to coordinate large buffalo hunts across millions of square kilometres, negotiate borders, form alliances and hold gatherings with thousands without uttering one word.
The Australian Aboriginal peoples developed similar skills, also related to hunting coordination, but also to complicated social rituals, including mourning practices under which women specifically were forbidden to speak, sometimes for months. Their hands remained their main tool for communication with the rest of the family and society.
What gesture does for you and for your audience
Not only is it a good exercise in intuition to second guess what the other might be meaning with their hands, but gesturing also helps you get your point across in the fastest of ways.
A study from 2025 conducted by UBC Sauder School of Business found that speaking with your hands makes you more persuasive. They analysed more than 2,000 TED talks using AI multimodal models, and the speakers who used their hands in a way that visually supported the point they were trying to make came across as much more competent than the others. The audience grasps their message faster because hand gesturing functions as an effective tool to aid the brains of the audience in understanding, and remembering, the point.
There is also something worth noticing in how they did it. Multimodal models now read gesture. What used to be invisible is becoming measurable with AI.
On the speaker side, talking with your hands provides cognitive offloading as well as aiding your mental file finding, supporting you in finding in your mental lexicon the most appropriate word to use. Susan Goldin-Meadow shows clearly that gesture is an integral part of the way we speak, and that restricting the hands measurably degrades the effectiveness of how well people explain and reason.
Audiences remember better when they can subconsciously use two parts of their brain to decode and remember, as explained by Allan Paivio’s dual coding theory, the one associated with words and the one associated with images.
Research from the Max Planck Institute for Psycholinguistics found that listeners were twenty per cent more likely to hear and remember a word correctly when a beat gesture fell on the stressed syllable. What is even more interesting is that when the gesture fell on the wrong syllable, listeners were forty per cent more likely to mishear the word altogether. So your hands have to be used coherently as they are an integral part of the signal, and out of time they can corrupt it.
Where AI fits and what to try this week
Try Voice mode. Speaking a problem aloud while moving your hands, then bringing the resolved version to the prompt, restores what typing removes.
Another thing worth trying is showing yourself from the waist up in your next video call. Your hands in sight, so that your audience gets a chance to benefit from seeing them moving as people will find following you easier. Framing that cuts you off at the shoulders removes the entire second channel, and the Max Planck finding suggests that is not neutral, it is lossy.
Stiff upper lip or open hands, the choice is yours
Do you want to learn how to talk with your hands well, or follow the old fashioned “composed” stiff upper lip etiquette that in my view was mainly effective from the Tudors onwards to keep population better under control with obsolete social conventions?
I have a feeling that intuition has been gradually and systematically trained out of us, and although I do not intend to go into the educational polemic or speculating on the political reasons why this might have been the case, I am feeling proud and lucky to be also Italian today, with dual citizenship, as I believe talking with my hands has helped me and my audiences a lot during the years.
I have a little treasure in my hands, like the little shell, a precious gift from my daughter, resting in my palm captured in the image I used for this piece, and you are welcome to start practicing too. Your intuition and audiences will benefit from it.
Next week
Next week, what changes the moment you say the problem out loud. Why people solve things halfway through explaining them to someone who has not said a word, and the strange but genuinely useful gift I received from my team in 2008.
If you are not yet following Intuition Edge, you can do that here:



I went through it and it's a brand new subject to share!