I always felt that receiving a gift tells you something about you. Sometimes it’s easier to decipher what the person offering you the gift is consciously or subconsciously trying to tell you. Some other times you are left puzzled as you really can’t connect the gift chosen with the message. In 2008 I received a 16 inch shiny, incredibly tacky gold skull and it turned out to be one of the most useful trinkets I owned.
After a year of working at AKQA, a highly innovative digital product design agency, as a global Group Director, my team gifted me, as a Secret Santa, the aforementioned super tacky golden skull. At first I was puzzled to say the least. Possibly slightly offended. Surely it was clear to all that I was more of a Missoni girl, classic, fun and colourful, rather than a stunning McQueen, and to top that, that golden skull was certainly not nearly as fashionable and cool as the ones used by the iconic British designer.
The loving banter from my colleagues explained it all. “Liv, next time don’t talk to us, talk to the skull, you got all the answers anyway.”
Little did I know at the time they had gifted me with my personalised version of Andrew Hunt and David Thomas’s rubber duck, nine years after the duck featured in The Pragmatic Programmer. A friendly object to talk to in order to articulate and strengthen my thinking. It turns out there is a lot of science behind what talking to yourself out loud does to validate your intuition.
Some of the science behind talking out loud
A lot has evolved since Jonathan Schooler stipulated that verbalising an intuitive judgement can degrade the judgement itself, rather than simply obscuring your ability to detect it. He went further and ran an experiment with Timothy Wilson, told by Malcolm Gladwell in Blink, where participants were asked to rank strawberry jams by quality. When simply asked to rate them on a first impression basis, novices and trained food experts alike all came broadly close to the rankings. When asked to explain their reasons and to write down what they thought and to break it down in areas such as taste, texture and more, the expert wildly outperformed the rest as the non-experts started to give answers they thought sounded proficient, and as a result got it quite wrong. The act of explaining muddled the judgement rather than improving it.
Frederick evolved this thinking significantly, speculating that intuition can lead to error if unchecked, yet he also recognised how useful it can be and the fact that the classic examples used in the Cognitive Reflection Test, such as the bat and ball below, are designed to trick.
A bat and a ball cost $1.10 in total. The bat costs $1.00 more than the ball. How much does the ball cost? _____ cents
Frederick might then imply that intuition is the error and reflection the fix, however, after more careful reading of the experiment, the winners seem to be the ones that are patient enough not to jump at the first conclusion available but going through the analytical process to validate it. To me, a very plausible read is that the patient one wins and, where possible, we should hold the signal long enough to be able to integrate it with other data to reach the right conclusion.
Here is the most recent counter argument
I was fascinated to read the Hu, Leppänen and Franco paper from 2025 as it states the opposite of what everybody assumes. The highest scorers on the test built to catch error-prone intuition were actually the ones relying on intuition the most. The authors are careful, and certainly they are not implying point blank that the reliance is what made them better. What I took from reading the experiment was that the fast signal arrives for everyone, yet what people do with it right after makes the difference. Not too far, if you think about it, from the point made earlier about patience being the quality often required to reach better decisions.
From my experience, when the answer is not black and white, and mathematical certainty cannot be obtained, I felt that having to explain away your intuitive signals too much degrades the quality of the answer and the direction that perhaps could have been more interesting to follow. Especially when you are dealing with innovation or original creativity where there aren’t many trodden paths to follow and data to produce a reliable benchmark might not be there yet.
Nonetheless we still live in a post-industrial world, where rational answers must be given. Even when working in a creative environment, we need well constructed, evidenced arguments to pass the test of our gatekeepers.
So use intuition, but put it on pause when circumstances allow, so that reasoning can come forward and interrogate what the first signal was suggesting. Then spend a lot of time post-rationalising and building the classic data-led story so that everyone else can get there too. Or just send them to my SPACE framework. Up to you.
Speak intuition and read to analyse
The bit of research that I found the most interesting of the lot I read for this piece was for sure the work of Janet Geipel and Boaz Keysar. They ran five experiments with over one thousand people and found that people respond more intuitively to spoken language and more analytically to written language. There is a moment for each and it is worth it, even if uncomfortable for some, not jumping ahead on the written modality prematurely. Equally, after a first intuitive signal is grasped, putting things together on paper might help the necessary analysis and integration on what to do with it.
With AI in the mix
We tend to talk to AI a lot at the moment, in a written form or using voice sometimes. If you type a prompt, you are choosing the analytic channel by default, whilst if you are talking to your LLM of choice, you are activating a different part of your brain.
AI cannot replace my skull, and the reason is that it talks back. And it does so prematurely, at a moment where more often than not what you actually need is a pause, giving your thoughts the chance to articulate and evolve so that they can become ready to be passed into the written, analytical form.
Committing too early to a prompt cuts the process short and commits you to an analytical way before the intuitive lawyer has had a chance to work its magic. I have said it many times as I develop my work and I will say it once more. I am not favouring intuitive signalling over analytical, I am simply evangelising fostering our intuition more, so that these signals can show up more clearly and we can use them alongside other data when they are ready to be used.
So what in practice?
I do not talk to my skull anymore and I have sadly lost it in my many moves since, but I am pushing you to find your companion object, talk to it, maybe the fern I suggested you should keep on your desk in to help with your attention. And possibly have an AI powered tool record the notes so you can do something with them later.
Also, if you have struggled interacting with colleagues who strongly prefer pre-reads ahead of conversations, forward them this piece and explain that they might be missing out on the chance to have an incredibly productive, if messy, creative brainstorm using each other’s intuitive signals in a free flowing conversation. You might even try it with your Board if the company is small, friendly and informal enough. You are always going to have the chance to commit what comes up to a written form for more analysis to follow.
Next week?
Next week, why the machine sounds so sure of itself, and why that confidence was not an accident of the technology but something we asked for and then rewarded. Or maybe the effects of “sleeping on it” and the proven benefits.
Having just spent a thousand words arguing that thinking happens when you say it aloud, whether I manage to write either depends on finding something else around the house to talk to, the skull being long gone. Then I will see which one my intuitive signalling asks me to sit down and formalise first.



Great piece. As much as we currently find ourselves in a period where the world depends on something that can be proven, its important not to lose touch with intuition because it is crude and it comes raw and fast. Trust your intuition, follow it, it usually explains itself later.
Amazing 😍